Aquaculture Plan Gets Select Board Nod

by William F. Galvin
Paul Wittenstein gets a commitment from the select board on his proposed Jack Knife Sea Farm aquaculture project proposed for Pleasant Bay. WILLIAM F. GALVIN PHOTO Paul Wittenstein gets a commitment from the select board on his proposed Jack Knife Sea Farm aquaculture project proposed for Pleasant Bay. WILLIAM F. GALVIN PHOTO

HARWICH – The proposal to place the first aquacultural farm in the Harwich waters of Pleasant Bay gained headway on Monday night when the select board approved the request to issue a license for Jack Knife Sea Farm.
 The proposal put forward by local resident Paul Wittenstein seeks to use 1.5 acres of the bay just off the Wequassett Resort and Golf Club to grow oyster, quahogs and potential other shellfish. The project has met with support from the Wequassett Resort.
 The select board’s decision depends on the proposal acquiring all the necessary approvals and permits required by local and state authorities. Three weeks ago, the conservation commission voted to continue its deliberations on the request until after the select board and Massachusetts Division of Marine Fisheries (MDM) declare their position on the request.
In Monday's presentation to the select board, Natural Resources Director Stephanie Ridenour said the town’s waterways committee is in support of the proposal. She said that she supports the request and has been examining the potential for aquaculture projects in local waters. There is a lot of interest in aquaculture in Pleasant Bay and other areas in town, but there have been a lot of non-starters because of navigational issues, she said, adding that there are several aquaculture sites in the Orleans section of Pleasant Bay. Her department is looking at establishing aquaculture regulations and fees.
Issues about the proposal were raised by Carole Ridley, coordinator for the Pleasant Bay Alliance, which is an oversight organization of the bay with representatives from Harwich, Chatham, Orleans and Brewster. Among those issues are impacts on the recreational use of the bay.
Ridenour said the gear associated with the farm will be located underwater so recreational activities can still take place. She recommended a condition be placed on the license prohibiting floating gear.
Ridley has said there was not enough information to conduct a proper review of the proposal. The alliance has requested more information on site conditions, sourcing of shellfish seed and the means of controlling conflicts with other activities occurring there.
 Select Board Chair Peter Piekarski also raised issues about the need for additional information on the proposal.
Ridenour pointed out that there is a long and thorough permitting process, and questions will be answered as it goes through the permitting process or the permits will not be issued. She cited requirements to obtain MDMF certification, including a survey of the proposal site, and the need to address issues such as natural shellfish production and whether eelgrass is located at the site. 
Ridenour said the survey will answer those questions, and if necessary adjustments can be made.
She also noted that shellfish are filter feeders that remove nitrogen from marine waters. 
 Wequassett welcomed the opportunity to promote environmental stewardship, education, eco-tourism and farm-to-table experiences, managing director Gary Thulander wrote in a letter to the town. 
 “We believe this proposal presents an exciting opportunity to further strengthen the connection between our resort, the locaI marine environment, and the broader community,” he wrote.
Pleasant Bay Community Boating also supports the project. Executive Director Dorothy Bassett wrote in a letter that the shellfish farm would not hamper recreational activities and would provide educational opportunities.
 “PBCB already collaborates with Paul, as he volunteers to manage and run our upweller (shellfish incubation system), which we use to teach children about mariculture and the food web,” she wrote.
 “With a shellfish grant so close by, we would be able to motor over to see the grant setup from the floating classroom pontoon boat, kids would be able to kayak over to make nature observations and get onsite lessons during grant tours, and we’ve talked with Paul about doing science days with kids and lectures for the community as part of our Speaker Series,” she wrote.
Jeffrey Lang, who received conservation commission approval to grow scallops in the Herring River, also supported the proposal.
 “The more aquaculture we do, the more immediate effect we have on reducing nitrogen,” he said.
The Pleasant Bay Alliance warned in a letter that “there is no method proposed to monitor, measure or document nitrogen filtering benefits of shellfish proposed to be grown on the site. Nor would such measures be recommended as the scale of impact is negligible in light of the town’s nitrogen management efforts for Pleasant Bay.” 
Select board member Jeffrey Handler praised Wittenstein and said the town’s local comprehensive plan calls for an increase in the “blue economy.”
Wittenstein, who is manager of the Aquacultural Research Corporation and has worked in the shellfish industry for 20 years, addressed several issues relating to gear, agreed to no floating gear and said there will be no trucks driving along the shoreline. Access will be provided through the Wequassett Resort, he said, adding that shellfish will be removed from the waters during the winter months to avoid ice damage.
The license request is for two years. Wittenstein said if the proposal shows success, he would be back before the board seeking a 10-year license agreement.
The board voted to approve the application pending receipt of all the necessary permits from the state and local agencies. The license would run through Nov. 15, 2028. A condition was added to prohibit floating gear.
The proposal will now move on to the state for review.