Detailed Info Sought On Crowell Rd. Intersection Project: Officials Want To Know What State Will And Won’t Accept
The Crowell Road-Route 28 intersection. FILE PHOTO
CHATHAM – In June, the select board voted to forgo $5 million in state and federal funding for proposed upgrading of the Crowell Road-Route 28 intersection. The plans developed by the town’s engineers, in compliance with state requirements, would have created a wide, urban-like intersection that is out of character with the community, board members said.
However, after receiving a response from the Massachusetts Department of Transportation (MassDOT) to questions about how the town might make its own changes to the intersection outside of the state and federal funding program, board members may be having second thoughts.
Not about accepting the money; board members made it clear at their Nov. 10 meeting that they have no intention of going back on their previous vote to remove the project from the county’s five-year transportation improvement plan (TIP). But they voted to ask the staff to craft a letter to MassDOT to identify elements of the intersection plan that the town found unacceptable and to ask whether any of those could be changed or altered to be more in keeping with community character.
Because, it turns out, any major improvements to the intersection that the town might undertake on its own would still have to comply with the MassDOT standards that board members and residents found unacceptable. And while the state will continue to maintain the roadway and signals at the intersection, should anything fail, it could be replaced with the same equipment that board members rejected as out of character for the town.
“I just want everybody to understand fully the repercussions of the vote not to continue on the TIP,” said Chair Jeffrey Dykens, the only board member to vote to support the project.
In an Oct. 20 letter, Mary-Joe Perry, MassDOT District 5 Highway Director, addressed several questions board members had about the intersection. Perry wrote that the state will continue to maintain “the existing traffic signal and intersection infrastructure through its routine maintenance program.” Should signal equipment fail, it would be replaced by the same equipment, but should that not be available, “MassDOT would likely replace existing signal components with standard galvanized steel signal posts and mast arms to restore or maintain functionality of the existing system,” Perry wrote.
The addition of modern signal equipment, including an overhead mast arm and pedestrian crossing lights, was one of the major objections to the intersection plan. While the state is apparently amenable to using “antique-style” signals and masts — the exact nature of which was not identified — should the current equipment fail, the town could end up with the exact signal equipment residents and officials said they did not want.
Even minor upgrades by the state, such as sidewalk and crosswalk improvements, would still require MassDOT planning and engineering and have to be added to the TIP for funding, Perry wrote.
Perry also wrote that if the town undertakes intersection improvements on its own, the plans would still undergo review by the agency and be required to adhere to “established MassDOT design policies and procedures” including Complete Streets. The latter program requires intermodal transportation lanes, including bike lanes, as well as upgraded sidewalks and pedestrian infrastructure, elements included in the state’s Crowell Road-Route 28 intersection improvement plan that local officials and some residents found objectionable.
Select board members had inquired about the town taking over jurisdiction for the intersection. Perry wrote the agency’s procedures for discontinuance of a state highway requires the discontinuation of a corridor, not just a single intersection. “A large section of state highway would need to be discontinued for this option to be considered,” she wrote.
Board members weren’t anxious to take ownership of the intersection and roadway and assume the financial responsibilities that entails.
“It’s a significant intersection, they need to take care of their responsibilities,” said board member Cory Metters.
“If [the state] wants to come in and make [the intersection] as ugly as they can, well, it’s on them,” said board member Stuart Smith. “But it’s going to be over our objections.”
“They could come in and do whatever they want to do; it’s their highway,” said board member Dean Nicastro. “They’re holding all the cards here.” He was critical of MassDOT’s Complete Highways program, which he said is responsible for many of the excesses that made the intersection plan so objectionable to many. “I don’t think there is massive public support to do what they want us to do,” he said.
Continuing to discuss the intersection with MassDOT ensures that the town could still have input into any changes, Dykens said. Otherwise “we’re going to get what we don’t want,” he said. “I don’t think that’s a prudent course of action.”
Smith said he believes the state is purposefully neglecting the intersection and continuing to deal with MassDOT will “give them cover” to make the unwanted changes anyway. The town’s legislative representatives should get involved, he added. “They need to do the work of the people,” he said.
Public Works Director Rob Faley said MassDOT replaced four posts at the intersection last year. “They are doing some maintenance there,” he said.
Steven Tupper, deputy director and transportation program director at the Cape Cod Commission, said if the town is clear about the intersection improvements it would accept, MassDOT could make adjustments.
“I’ve seen this situation before that’s ended up with a positive project,” he said.
Smith said he is not optimistic about how the state will respond, but he said setting down the elements the town wants and doesn’t want will create a basis for moving forward.
A healthy Barnstable County requires great community news.
Please support The Cape Cod Chronicle by subscribing today!
Please support The Cape Cod Chronicle by subscribing today!
Loading...