Assessment Outlines 20-Year Facilities Plan
A new facilities assessment identifies $350,000 worth of accessibility improvements at Orleans Elementary School. FILE PHOTO
ORLEANS – A new assessment of town facilities has identified approximately $23 million worth of maintenance work needed over the next five years and north of $109 million through fiscal 2047.
The assessment conducted by the firm Bureau Veritas took into account observations of town facilities, interviews with staff, and facilities and maintenance records. It looked at 31 town facilities “and related assets,” among them town buildings, Orleans Elementary School, the town’s water and wastewater infrastructure and its beach and park facilities.
“We’re talking about water pumps, we’re talking about landings,” Finance Director Darrin Tangeman told the select board in his presentation of the assessment Nov. 4. “There’s lots of variations.”
Tangeman said that the town is looking at $4.62 million a year in maintenance costs on average between FY28 and FY32. Water-related costs could be covered through both water fees and the state revolving fund, leaving approximately $2.5 million a year that could be covered through the creation of an override-funded stabilization account.
Top Priorities
Among the most highly prioritized buildings identified in the assessment is Orleans Elementary School. The school dates to 1956 and was added on to in 1988. The $23,089,690 in costs over the next five years includes $576,215 in “accessibility allowances,” including $350,000 for the elementary school.
Tangeman noted that the elementary school maintenance funding is separate from a 2023 study looking at the cost of renovating the existing structure versus building a new school. That study looked at a $23 million renovation which would have triggered an additional $2.8 million worth of mandatory accessibility upgrades, he said.
“We’re looking to maintain the property in its current state and keep it in a safe and accessible state for its current occupants, versus adding another floor or doing other things to it,” he said.
Recommended accessibility improvements for the elementary school include two accessible restrooms, accessible drinking fountains, an accessible entranceway as well as “controls and signage” and accessible front parking, curb ramps and approach.
Funding for accessibility improvements has also been earmarked for Snow Library ($105,156), the water department ($95,898) and housing ($25,161).
Higher Costs In FY29
While the projected annual maintenance costs are largely consistent from year to year, the projected $12,149,130 called for in FY29 is an outlier. That figure includes $7.75 million related to expanding the town’s water treatment facility and water storage coating.
At the far end of the 20-year timeline, approximately $44.9 million is forecasted for FY47, with that money going to replace two water towers and a water tank and new building controls for the elementary school. Tangeman said the water replacements would likely qualify for low interest state revolving fund loans.
How To Fund It?
The assessment calls for the creation of a dedicated maintenance stabilization account through a town meeting vote. The account would be funded through a Proposition 2½ override.
If adopted, voters would need to approve the select board’s annual recommended funding for the account through a two-thirds vote at town meeting. The select board is authorized to raise the annual appropriation by as much as 2.5 percent from the current year. It also can fund the account at a lower amount, or defer funding it at all.
For water-related maintenance, the town could apply for SRF funding. But Tangeman also noted that the town’s existing water fee structure will also need to be reevaluated to keep up with the costs associated with the 20-year plan.
“There will need to be a conversation looking at the fee structure, fee modeling for water and whether or not we get it set up on a trajectory that allows us to fund this capital 20 years out and also conduct operations,” he said.
Kevin Galligan of the select board said that if the town wants to try its hand at SRF funding, planning needs to begin now. That includes submission of a project evaluation form to the state, he said.
“This is not a one-sheet piece of paper,” he said. “This is a very significant preliminary design supported with the need, early estimates that needs to go into SRF by this July.” Calvin Sutton, the town’s deputy public works director, said that the town does plan to explore funding through the SRF program, and that it is working with the firm Wright Pierce on an application.
Other Considerations
Tangeman said that there would likely also be staffing considerations involved with the long-term maintenance plan. He said that as is, the town does not have the staff needed to carry out the work as outlined over the next 20 years.
Mark Mathison of the select board asked if it would be on the town to fund its own individual or persons to help oversee the work, or if there are options for sharing that role with other towns as a regional position. Town Manager Kim Newman said with the amount of work involved in just Orleans, a regional position may not be feasible
“It’s a lot of work to get caught up to get going, is my point,” she said. “In particular, the other nuance here is it’s uniquely our stuff.” Newman said a position will likely be added to the public works budget “to help facilitate” the maintenance program.
Select Board Chair Mefford Runyon noted that the assessment did not take into account wastewater infrastructure. Galligan noted that the wastewater treatment plant only recently went online in 2023.
“This is looking at, at least as I see it, needs that have not been tended to,” he said.
A healthy Barnstable County requires great community news.
Please support The Cape Cod Chronicle by subscribing today!
Please support The Cape Cod Chronicle by subscribing today!
Loading...